Why Hasn’t the Falling Loonie Done More for our Exports?

Canadian exports of manufactured goods1 to the United States almost caught up to the levels reached before the financial crisis. Recent growth has been fast, with an annual average of 6.9% since 20092.

The bad news: this surge draws attention away from Canada’s declining share of the U.S. market relative to other countries. This decline is particularly noteworthy given that exports of manufactured goods have been a driver of Canadian GDP growth since 20093 and that the U.S. is still—by far—the main destination for Canadian manufactured goods (79% in 20144). Canada’s share of the U.S. market gradually fell from 15% in 2005 to 11% in 20145. It would be too easy to link this deterioration to China’s well-known performance6; indeed, other countries were able to maintain, and in some cases, actually increase their share of the U.S. market during the past decade:

  • Mexico: increased its share of the U.S. market for imported manufactured goods from 10% to 13%;
  • Euro Zone countries7: maintained their market share of close to 16%.

Share of U.S. market for imported manufactured goods1 — by
most important regions of origin — 2005-2014
Share of U.S. market for imported manufactured goods — by most important regions of origin — 2005-2014
Source : US Census Bureau.

Canadian authorities had high hopes that the depreciation of the Canadian dollar vis-à-vis the U.S. dollar (a 20% decline within the last 24 months8) would stimulate exports to the U.S. This depreciation, however, is not limited to the Canadian dollar. The value of other currencies (relative to the U.S. dollar) also fell—the euro and the peso lost 30% and 20% of their value, respectively, relative to the U.S. dollar within the last 24 months9—eliminating any advantage Canadian exporters might have enjoyed over their rivals targeting the same market.

The possibility of a trade agreement between the U.S. and the European Union (Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership – TTIP) will do nothing to improve Canadian export prospects to the U.S.

******

[1] Code 31-33 of North American Industry Classification System (NAICS).
[2] Up to the end of 2014. Manufactured goods accounted for 63% of the total value of Canadian exports. Note that during this time (2009-2014), the value of U.S. imports of manufactured goods rose at an average annual nominal growth rate of 9.3%. Sources: US Census Bureau and Industry Canada (according to Statistics Canada and US Census Bureau).
[3] Exports from Canada’s manufacturing industries grew at a higher average annual rate than the GDP between 2009 and 2014. Source: based on data from Industry Canada and Statistics Canada.
[4] Source: Industry Canada (according to Statistics Canada and US Census Bureau).
[5] Source: US Census Bureau. Note that there is no exact match between the value of Canadian exports to the U.S. (based on Industry Canada data) and the value of U.S. imports from Canada (based on U.S. Census Bureau data). The difference has typically been in the order of 15% during the last decade.
[6] In 10 years, China’s market share of U.S. imports of manufactured goods rose from 18% to 24% (2005-2014).
[7] Includes the 19 member countries as of July 2015.
[8] Source: Board of Governor of the Federal Reserve System, Foreign Exchange Rates, G.5 Statistical Release – Monthly rates, consulted on July 10 2015.
[9] Idem.

 

 

LinkedIn Twitter Email

E&B DATA – NEWSLETTER

* indicates required


 

Latest Edition of
MEGAPROJECTS OUTLOOK – CANADA:

Megaproject outlook - 4Q14-F_Page_1

Megaproject outlook - 4Q14-F_Page_2

Megaproject outlook - 4Q14-F_Page_3

« Fluctuat nec mergitur »

Learn More

Comments are closed.